Remember that episode of Seinfeld where they wait forever for a table at a Chinese restaurant? Or that episode of Friends where everyone finds out about Monica and Chandler having sex? Or even the episode of The Simpsons where Lisa decides to become a vegetarian?
I'd want my public access show to be a bunch of regular people re-enacting these episodes. Verbatim. No one is trying to be bad on purpose. Everything just happens to be amateur-ish because it's being produced by amateurs.
That would be my show.